Comparing Top Hiking Shoes from Columbia and KEEN

Hey there! Choosing the right hiking shoe is crucial for anyone who loves to hit the trails, and I’ve had the pleasure of exploring three stellar options: the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe, the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes, and the Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe. Whether you’re a casual hiker, enjoy rugged trails, or need something reliable under various weather conditions, these shoes each bring something unique to the table. Trust me, your feet will thank you for finding the perfect pair!

Hiking shoes have come a long way from their early days. Originally serving as simple protective gear for adventurers, today’s hiking shoes are engineered marvels designed for comfort, support, and durability. Modern advancements have introduced features like waterproofing, heat insulation, and enhanced grip, making these shoes an essential investment for anyone serious about outdoor activities. Owning a pair of quality hiking shoes means enjoying better foot support, reduced risk of injury, and an all-around more enjoyable hiking experience.

So, let’s take a closer look at what each of these hiking shoes has to offer. We’ll explore the unique benefits and features of the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe, the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoe, and the Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe. By the end of this review, you’ll have a clear idea of which pair might be your new best trail companion!

Columbia Women’s Hiking Shoe

Columbia Womens Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe

When it comes to choosing the right hiking shoe, it’s essential to consider what you’ll primarily be using it for. The Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe is designed to tackle a variety of terrains and weather conditions. Whether you’re trekking through damp, forested trails or rocky mountain paths, this shoe is your versatile ally. Thanks to its waterproof and thermal features, it’s particularly well-suited for hikes in cooler climates where moisture and cold might otherwise be an issue.

What stands out about the Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat is its ability to perform in wet and cold conditions. Columbia’s Omni-Tech construction ensures that your feet stay dry, while the Omni-Heat reflective lining traps and reuses body heat to keep your feet warm.

Crafted from PU-coated leather, suede, and a mesh upper with durable metal hardware, this hiking shoe is built to last. The materials are both lightweight and robust, providing the perfect balance of comfort and longevity. Additionally, it offers excellent support, reducing the risk of ankle injuries on uneven terrain.

Another reason to love this product is the Omni-Grip rubber outsole. Made with 20% regrind/recycled rubber flecks, it delivers remarkable traction on various surfaces while also contributing to environmental sustainability.

The Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe is designed with a specific purpose in mind—to provide a reliable, comfortable, and eco-friendly hiking experience in cold and wet environments.

  • Waterproof Design: The Omni-Tech construction includes a PU-coated leather, suede, and mesh upper, effectively sealing out wet weather.
  • Thermal Insulation: The Omni-Heat reflective lining amplifies natural foot warmth.
  • Exceptional Traction: The Omni-Grip rubber outsole, made with regrind/recycled rubber flecks, ensures sturdy grip across multiple terrains.
  • Sturdy Build: Durable metal hardware and high-quality materials like leather and suede enhance both robustness and longevity.
  • Variety of Colors: Columbia offers these hiking boots in multiple colors, allowing you to choose one that fits your personal style.

You’ll notice the quality craftsmanship as soon as you lace up these hiking shoes. Every component, from the PU-coated leather to the metal hardware, is selected to last through numerous hikes and various conditions. The stitching is precise, providing additional durability, while the reflective lining not only keeps you warm but also demonstrates advanced engineering.

The materials feel neither too stiff nor too soft, giving you the right amount of flexibility and support. The Omni-Grip rubber outsole provides stable footing even on slick or uneven surfaces, enhancing both safety and performance. Moreover, Columbia’s attention to detail is evident in the proper alignment and integration of all these elements, making these shoes a reliable choice for any hiker.

  • Excellent Weather Protection: The waterproof construction and thermal lining make these shoes ideal for hiking in wet and cold conditions.

  • Durable Materials: PU-coated leather, suede, and metal hardware ensure these shoes can withstand rugged use.

  • Eco-Friendly Traction: The inclusion of recycled rubber in the outsole design adds an eco-conscious element to its already impressive grip.

  • Comfortable Fit: True-to-size fitting ensures comfort from the first wear, reducing the need for a break-in period.

  • Versatile Colors: Multiple color options make it easy to find a pair that matches your style.

  • Weight: While the materials used are designed for durability and weather resistance, they can make the shoes a bit heavier compared to other hiking footwear options.

  • Breathability: The excellent thermal insulation might cause your feet to become too warm in milder temperatures, reducing overall breathability in such conditions.

  • Cost: High-quality materials and innovative features come at a price, making these shoes a bit of an investment.

See also  Beach Chair Showdown: Tommy Bahama vs KingCamp vs Coleman

Ultimately, the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe is a solid choice for those keen on adventures in diverse and challenging environments. You’ll appreciate the combination of weather protection, durability, and eco-friendly design, making every hike more comfortable and sustainable.

Columbia Womens Hiking Shoe

KEEN Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes

KEEN Mens Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes

When you’re on the hunt for versatile hiking shoes that can transition seamlessly from rugged trails to casual urban environments, the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes is equipped to meet your needs. Whether you’re an experienced hiker looking to conquer more advanced trails or a beginner eager to explore the great outdoors, these shoes are designed to be your reliable partner.

Let’s talk about the dual nature of the Targhee 2 shoes. The blend of an athletic shoe’s comfort and a hiking boot’s durability makes it a go-to choice for diverse activities. The removable dual-density EVA footbed adds an unrivaled layer of comfort, hugging the natural contours of your feet. So, whether you’re on a short day hike or a multi-day backpacking trip, your feet remain well-supported and cushioned.

One of the standout features we can’t overlook is the KEEN.Dry waterproof membrane. This clever technology keeps your feet dry without compromising breathability. Tackling a wet, muddy trail? Not an issue. Worried about your feet overheating on sunny hikes? These shoes have you covered. It’s that elusive combination of waterproofing and breathability that makes these shoes a solid choice for various weather conditions.

The primary purpose of the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes is to offer dependable performance across varying terrains. Equipped with multi-directional, 4-millimeter lugs, these shoes provide dependable traction on slippery and uneven surfaces. You won’t be worrying about losing your grip, no matter the trail conditions.

Hiking trails can be littered with rocks, roots, and other obstacles. The patented Keen.Protect toe protection extends up and over the outsole, giving your toes complete coverage and shielding them from injuries. This feature is a lifesaver on rugged terrains where a stubbed toe can ruin your day.

Shock, Suspension, and Stability (S3) are critical for any serious hiker. This feature of the Targhee 2 shoes ensures that your heel is supported on impact, dissipating shock and helping to prevent ankle injuries. The combination of this S3 heel structure with a torsional-stability ESS shank minimizes foot fatigue, ensuring you can go the extra mile comfortably.

Functionality doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice style. These shoes feature a waterproof nubuck upper with modern stitching accents and pops of color, making them as visually appealing as they are functional. Whether you’re exploring the trails or hitting the town, these shoes manage to look good in both settings.

The materials used in the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes are top-tier — from the waterproof nubuck upper to the KEEN.Dry membrane lining. These materials are designed to withstand the wear and tear of hiking while still providing a comfortable and secure fit.

Attention to detail in craftsmanship is evident throughout these shoes. Every stitch serves a purpose, enhancing durability while also contributing to the shoe’s overall aesthetic. The combination of high-quality materials and expert construction ensures that these shoes can endure the toughest conditions you might encounter.

The durability of these shoes is impressive. The rugged build provides longevity even with frequent use. The non-marking rubber outsole further enhances the shoe’s lifespan, resisting wear while providing excellent traction. These aren’t shoes you’ll need to replace any time soon.

  • Comfortable and Supportive: The dual-density EVA midsole and removable EVA footbed offer exceptional comfort and support, making these shoes perfect for long hikes.

  • Waterproof and Breathable: Thanks to the KEEN.Dry waterproof membrane, your feet stay dry in wet conditions, yet can breathe in warmer weather.

  • Excellent Traction: The 4-millimeter multi-directional lugs are perfect for diverse terrains, providing top-notch traction.

  • Toe Protection: The patented Keen.Protect toe protection adds a crucial layer of safety against trail obstacles.

  • Stylish Design: The combination of sporty design and practical features means you don’t have to compromise style for functionality.

  • Weight: At 16.64 ounces (472.58 grams), some users find these shoes a bit on the heavier side, especially for longer hikes.

  • Break-in Period: Like many robust hiking shoes, the Targhee 2 may require a bit of breaking in before achieving maximum comfort.

  • Price: While the quality justifies the cost, the Targhee 2 shoes can be a bit pricey for budget-conscious hikers.

See also  Top 3 Heavy Duty Beach Umbrellas Compared for High Wind

Whether you’re gearing up for a big adventure or just need a reliable pair for everyday use, the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes promise to deliver comfort, durability, and versatility. It’s a solid investment for anyone serious about hiking and outdoor activities.

KEEN Mens Waterproof Hiking Shoes

Columbia Men’s Waterproof Hiking Boot

Columbia mens Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe

The Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe is designed for the dedicated hiking enthusiast who’s looking to tackle a wide range of terrains. Whether you’re embarking on a rigorous day hike, exploring backcountry trails, or navigating mountainous regions, these boots are engineered to support you every step of the way. Their expert design caters to those who appreciate both the function and style in their outdoor footwear.

Durability and Comfort are two standout reasons why we love the Columbia Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe. The superior craftsmanship ensures that these boots stand up to wear and tear without sacrificing comfort. They combine rugged materials with a design that minimizes foot fatigue, making them an excellent choice for long hikes.

Moreover, the incorporation of Columbia’s signature technology means these boots are built for high-quality protection and prevention against natural elements. The waterproof exterior is particularly beneficial for those unpredictable weather days, ensuring your feet remain dry and comfortable.

The purpose of the Columbia Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe is to provide an optimal hiking experience by blending rugged durability and unmatched comfort. Here’s a closer look at the key features that make these boots exceptional:

  • Waterproof Mesh and Leather Exterior: Offers robust protection against wet conditions and rough terrain. The combination of mesh and leather ensures that the boots breathe while keeping your feet dry.

  • Advanced Traction Outsole: With a focus on an advanced traction outsole, these boots excel in providing excellent grip across diverse environments – from slick streams to gravel paths.

  • Lightweight Midsole: The lightweight midsole is designed to cushion each step, providing long-lasting comfort and superior shock absorption. This feature enhances energy return, ensuring that you maintain your stride effortlessly.

  • Available in Multiple Colors and Sizes: To cater to individual preferences and ensure a perfect fit, the boots come in various colors and sizes. Columbia also provides a sizing chart to aid you in selecting the ideal size.

The Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe exemplifies high-quality craftsmanship. The meticulously chosen materials demonstrate Columbia’s dedication to producing long-lasting and comfortable outdoor gear. The boots’ sleek design does not compromise their functional aspects, an essential factor for any serious hiker.

The waterproofing is particularly impressive, with the boots holding up exceptionally well in both wet and dry conditions. This makes them versatile enough to tackle differing trail scenarios. The combination of a lightweight midsole and an advanced traction outsole creates a balance of stability and agility, key elements for preserving foot health during extensive hiking sessions.

  • Durable Construction: The blend of mesh and leather, reinforced with superior stitching, makes these boots resilient to the elements and trail abrasion.

  • Waterproof Performance: Exceptional waterproof capability ensuring your feet remain dry even in wetter terrains.

  • Comfortable: High-quality cushioning in the midsole provides impressive impact absorption, reducing fatigue during long hikes.

  • Advanced Outsole Traction: Enhanced grip on various surfaces, ensuring stability whether you’re going uphill or down.

  • Stylish Design: Available in multiple colors, these boots offer a blend of aesthetics and function.

  • Break-in Period: Some users might find that there’s a slight break-in period where the boots may feel stiff before conforming to your feet.

  • Sizing: Although available in various sizes, it is crucial to utilize the sizing chart to determine the correct fit, as inappropriate sizing can affect comfort levels.


The Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe is a meticulously designed boot ideal for those who demand durability, comfort, and style on the trail. Whether you’re dealing with muddy pathways or rocky inclines, these boots offer the protection and support needed to enhance your hiking experience.

Columbia Mens Waterproof Hiking Boot

Comparison of Hiking Shoes

In order to assist you in choosing the best hiking shoes for your next adventure, here’s a detailed comparison of three top-rated products: the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe, KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes, and Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe. These shoes stand out for their unique features, promising excellent performance across various terrains. Let’s break down their specifications to see which might suit you best.

See also  Comparing Top Lifejackets: NRS, Onyx, and Kent Options

Specifications Overview

Feature Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Columbia Men’s Crestwood
Waterproof Yes Yes Yes
Material PU-coated leather, suede, mesh Nubuck and textile Mesh and leather
Weight Not specified 16.64 oz / 472.58 g Not specified
Lining Omni-Heat reflective KEEN.Dry waterproof membrane Unspecified
Midsole Unspecified Dual-density, compression-molded EVA Lightweight cushioning
Special Technology Omni-Tech construction, Omni-Heat S3 heel structure, Keen Metatomical footbed, ESS shank Signature technology for cushioning and energy return
Traction Omni-Grip rubber outsole 4-mm multi-directional lugs Advanced traction outsole
Toe Protection Unspecified Keen.Protect Unspecified
Colors Multiple Multiple Multiple
Sizes True-to-size Custom fit with lace-up front True-to-size

Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe

If you’re looking for a blend of warmth and waterproofing, the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat might be just what you need. This shoe features Omni-Tech construction and PU-coated leather, suede, and mesh upper, which effectively seals out wet weather while providing ventilation. An Omni-Heat reflective lining ensures natural foot warmth, making it perfect for cold-weather hikes. The Omni-Grip rubber outsole, with recycled rubber flecks, provides excellent traction on a variety of surfaces.

KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes

For a combination of athletic comfort and rugged durability, the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 is a solid choice. This shoe stands out with its waterproof nubuck upper and KEEN.Dry membrane that keeps your feet dry and comfortable. The S3 heel structure provides outstanding support and prevents ankle injuries. Additionally, the dual-density EVA midsole and Keen Metatomical footbed guarantee long-lasting support and comfort. The 4-mm multi-directional lugs on the outsole deliver excellent traction, while the patented Keen.Protect technology offers enhanced toe protection.

Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe

The Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe is designed for durability, comfort, and reliability on the trail. Featuring a waterproof mesh and leather exterior, this shoe protects against various elements. Its advanced traction outsole ensures a firm grip on multiple terrains, effectively preventing slips. The lightweight midsole offers superb cushioning and energy return, making it ideal for extended hikes.

Final Thoughts

All three hiking shoes – Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus, KEEN Men’s Targhee 2, and Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid – bring distinct advantages to the table. Depending on your needs, whether it’s superior warmth, comprehensive support, or a blend of comfort and durability, there’s a pair here for you. Choose the one that aligns best with your hiking style, and you’ll be ready to conquer any trail with confidence!

Conclusion

After reviewing the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe, KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes, and Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe, it’s easy to see that each product shines in its own right, catering to various hiking enthusiasts with specific needs and preferences.

Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe

This shoe offers excellent warmth and comfort, making it a fantastic choice for women who hike in cooler climates. The Omni-Heat technology ensures your feet stay toasty, while the sturdy build provides good support and durability. However, some users have reported that the sizing runs a bit small, so be sure to try them on before setting off on your next adventure.

KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes

KEEN’s Targhee 2 is a versatile option for men who seek a blend of comfort, durability, and waterproof capabilities. These shoes are perfect for tackling a variety of terrains, from muddy trails to rocky paths. Just be aware that they might feel slightly heavy if you’re used to more lightweight footwear. Nonetheless, their robust nature and excellent traction make them a reliable choice for versatile hikers.

Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe

The Columbia Crestwood Mid offers great mid-level ankle support and waterproof protection without sacrificing comfort. They are particularly well-suited for men looking for dependable footwear on moderate trails. A possible drawback could be their minimal arch support, which might not be ideal for those with specific arch requirements. Consider adding custom insoles for extra comfort if needed.

Recommendation

For women who love winter hikes or cooler climates, the Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Omni Heat Hiking Shoe is your perfect match. Men seeking a rugged, capable shoe for diverse hiking conditions should opt for the KEEN Men’s Targhee 2 Low Height Waterproof Hiking Shoes. Lastly, if you prioritize ankle support and waterproof features on moderate trails, the Columbia Men’s Crestwood Mid Waterproof Hiking Shoe will serve you well.

In summary, each of these hiking shoes excels in different areas, ensuring there’s a suitable choice for every type of hiker. Happy hiking!

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.