Comparing Top MTB Helmets: Giro, Troy Lee, SMITH

Hey there! If you’re an avid mountain biker, you know the importance of having a high-quality helmet. With so many options out there, finding the right one can be quite the adventure. Today, we’re comparing three standout helmets: the Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet for men, the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS, and the SMITH Convoy MTB Cycling Helmet with MIPS technology. Each of these comes packed with features that promise safety and comfort on the trails. So, grab a coffee, and let’s chat about these fantastic options.

Mountain biking helmets have come a long way over the years. Originally, bike helmets were quite basic, aimed merely at providing a bit of protection for your head. But as mountain biking has evolved into a more extreme sport with higher speeds and rugged terrains, so too have the helmets. Enter the modern era with advanced materials, engineering marvels, and smart technologies like MIPS (Multi-directional Impact Protection System) that reduce rotational forces on the brain during impacts. Owning a top-quality helmet is not just about safety—though that’s crucial—it’s also about enhancing your riding experience with better comfort, ventilation, and fit.

In this article, we’ll explore each of these three helmets in more detail. We’ll look into the unique features of the Giro Manifest Spherical, the innovative design of the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic, and the smart technology in the SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet. Buckle up as we break down what makes each of these helmets special and help you find the perfect one for your next adventure.

Table of Contents

Giro Manifest Men’s Cycling Helmet

The Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet is designed specifically for mountain biking enthusiasts. Whether you’re tackling rugged trails, conquering steep descents, or navigating through challenging terrain, this helmet is crafted to provide you with superior protection and performance. Its unique design and innovative features make it an excellent choice for avid mountain bikers who demand the best in safety and comfort.

The Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet stands out in a crowded marketplace for its Spherical Technology, powered by MIPS impact management. This design ensures a higher level of safety by reducing rotational forces during impacts, helping to protect your brain from injury. This forward-thinking approach to helmet construction pairs well with its high-level comfort and aerodynamics.

The helmet features 19 Wind Tunnel Vents with internal channeling. This means you get unparalleled airflow and ventilation, keeping you cool even on the most intense rides. The Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System ensures a snug, customizable fit, which is essential for both safety and comfort over prolonged use. Additionally, the helmet is relatively lightweight, coming in at only 340g (Size Medium), making it a joy to wear for long periods.

The primary aim of the Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet is to provide the highest level of safety and comfort for mountain bikers. Whether you’re a casual weekend rider or a seasoned professional, this helmet is designed to offer dependable protection and a comfortable fit, enabling you to focus more on the trail and less on your gear.

Spherical Technology, Powered By MIPS Impact Management:
- Enhances safety by managing rotational forces, effectively reducing the likelihood of serious brain injuries during crashes.
In-Mold Construction With Progressive Layering:
- This design offers superior impact absorption while keeping the helmet lightweight. Full lower Hardbody Coverage adds an extra layer of durability.
19 Wind Tunnel Vents With Internal Channeling:
- Optimizes airflow to keep you cool during intense rides, preventing overheating and ensuring you remain comfortable.
Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System:
- Provides a highly adjustable and secure fit, tailored to your unique head shape.
Product Weight: 340g (Size Medium CPSC, CE):
- Strikes a perfect balance between sturdiness and comfort with minimal weight.

The overall quality of the Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet is impressive. For those who place a high value on safety, this helmet makes a compelling argument with its Spherical Technology and MIPS integration, which work in tandem to safeguard your head during impacts. The In-Mold construction provides durability without adding unnecessary weight, making it a practical choice for extended wear.

The helmet is also incredibly breathable, thanks to its 19 strategically placed vents, and the Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System ensures a customizable fit that doesn’t compromise on comfort or security. The materials used are of high quality, ensuring longevity and sustained performance even under harsh conditions.

Advanced Safety Features: The combination of Spherical Technology and MIPS provides top-notch protection against impacts and rotational forces.
Exceptional Ventilation: The 19 Wind Tunnel Vents with internal channeling keep you cool during long, strenuous bike rides.
Customizable Fit: The Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System offers excellent adjustability, ensuring a secure and comfortable fit.
Lightweight: At only 340g, it doesn’t weigh you down, making it easier to wear for extended periods.
Durable Construction: The In-Mold construction with Progressive Layering gives you the confidence that your helmet can take a beating and still perform.
Price: The advanced technology and high-quality materials come at a cost, making the Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet a bit of an investment.
Limited Color Options: While the design is sleek, those looking for a wide range of colors might find the options somewhat restrictive.
Fit Adjustments: Although the Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System is highly customizeable, it may take a bit of tinkering to get it perfect for your personal preference.

The Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet is a well-rounded piece of protective gear that excels in safety, comfort, and functionality. Its advanced safety features and excellent ventilation are particularly impressive, making it a reliable companion for any mountain biking adventure.

Troy Lee Designs Adult Mountain Bike Helmet with MIPS

The Troy Lee Designs Adult A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS is primarily designed for all-mountain mountain biking. This helmet is suitable for a range of terrains, making it ideal for everything from casual trail rides to more aggressive downhill runs. Whether you’re pedaling through forested paths, rocky descents, or technical singletracks, this helmet has you covered.

We love the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet for several reasons. Firstly, it’s a blend of safety and comfort. With a reinforced polycarbonate shell and MIPS technology, it offers top-notch protection. Additionally, the 16 vented ports ensure you stay cool even during the most intense rides. This helmet is also highly adjustable, ensuring a customized fit suitable for all head shapes and sizes. The plush comfort liner, which is both removable and washable, makes it easy to keep your helmet fresh and clean.

The purpose of the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS is to provide robust protection and unparalleled comfort while maintaining a stylish look, characteristic of the brand’s racing heritage.

Safety:
- Reinforced polycarbonate shell in-molded with EPS liner.
- MIPS technology (Multi-directional Impact Protection System), which reduces rotational forces during impacts.
Cooling System:
- A total of 16 vented ports (8 front and 8 back) to ensure maximum airflow and heat dissipation.
Adjustability:
- Triple position adjustable retention system for a perfect fit.
- Adaptable to different head shapes and compatible with various eyewear types.
Comfort:
- Single piece, ultra-plush comfort liner that is removable and washable.
- Adjustable visor to protect from sun and debris.
Troy Lee Heritage:
- Designed and developed from over 40 years of racing experience in Corona, California.

The overall quality of the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet is exceptional, living up to the high standards set by the brand. The helmet’s combination of durability, protection, and comfort makes it a standout choice in the crowded field of mountain bike helmets. The craftsmanship is evident in the fine details, from the in-molded polycarbonate shell to the meticulously designed venting systems. The use of premium materials, such as the ultra-plush comfort liner, enhances both the helmet’s feel and functionality. Additionally, the integration of MIPS technology further elevates the helmet’s protective capabilities.

Superior Protection: With its reinforced polycarbonate shell and EPS liner, along with MIPS technology, the helmet offers comprehensive protection against both direct and rotational impacts.
Excellent Ventilation: The 16 vented ports (8 at the front and 8 at the back) ensure you stay cool, making it ideal for long rides in hot conditions.
Adjustability: The triple position adjustable retention system and adaptable fit make this helmet suitable for a variety of head shapes and eyewear options.
Comfortable Liner: The single piece, ultra-plush comfort liner is not only comfortable but also removable and washable, simplifying maintenance.
Adjustable Visor: The adjustable visor provides additional protection from sun glare and debris, enhancing your riding experience.
Weight: At 13.2 ounces, it’s slightly heavier compared to some other lightweight helmets on the market, which might be a consideration if you’re looking for the lightest option.
Price: The premium features and materials come with a higher price tag, which might be a deterrent for budget-conscious riders.
Design: While the design is stylish and rooted in racing heritage, it might not appeal to riders who prefer a more understated look.

If you’re in the market for a high-quality, all-mountain helmet that prioritizes protection and comfort without compromising on style, the Troy Lee Designs Adult A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS is a fantastic choice.

SMITH Convoy MTB Adult Bike Helmet with MIPS and Visor – Lightweight Impact Protection

The SMITH Convoy MTB Cycling Helmet is designed with mountain biking at its core. Whether you’re tackling rugged terrains or cruising along scenic trails, this helmet delivers top-notch performance every single time. Its lightweight design ensures you won’t feel bogged down, making it perfect for day-long adventures. If you’re keen on safety and comfort while maneuvering through challenging trails, this helmet will quickly become your go-to gear.

What makes the SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet stand out is its thoughtful design tailored for mountain bikers. The helmet not only prioritizes safety with MIPS technology but also focuses on comfort and functionality. Its 20 fixed vents offer optimal ventilation, while the AirEvac system ensures that those annoying foggy lenses are a thing of the past. Plus, its custom-tailored fit with the adjustable dial at the back makes sure you have a snug yet comfortable experience every single ride.

The primary purpose of the SMITH Convoy is to offer lightweight impact protection for mountain bikers, which it accomplishes seamlessly. Here are some of its key features:

Lightweight Protection: The helmet ensures you remain protected without burdening you with extra weight.
MIPS Safety Protection System: This technology adds an extra layer of protection by reducing rotational forces in the event of an impact.
Fixed Visor: Keeps your eyes shielded from the sun and debris.
Ventilation: With 20 fixed vents, you get consistent airflow—keeping you cool on the hottest days.
AirEvac System: Specifically designed to integrate with Smith eyewear, keeping your glasses fog-free.
Adjustable Fit: The adjustable dial at the back allows for a comfortable and personalized fit.
Certification: The helmet is CPSC & CE EN 1078 certified, ensuring it meets rigorous safety standards.

These features collectively make the SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet a robust protective gear for both men and women who are passionate about mountain biking.

When it comes to overall quality, the SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet is among the best in the market. Built from innovative materials, this helmet embodies durability and advanced technology. The build quality ensures that you have a long-lasting helmet that performs exceptionally well in real-world MTB scenarios. The ventilation system, safety features, and comfort-focused design all speak volumes about the thought process and engineering prowess behind this product.

MIPS Technology: Offers superior protection by reducing rotational forces during impacts.
Excellent Ventilation: 20 fixed vents provide ample airflow, keeping you cool.
Fog-Free Integration: The AirEvac system aligns perfectly with Smith eyewear, eliminating foggy lenses.
Adjustable Fit: Easily customizable using the dial at the back for a snug yet comfortable fit.
Lightweight: Provides substantial protection without the added bulk, ideal for long rides.
Certification: Meets CPSC & CE EN 1078 safety standards, giving you peace of mind.
Fixed Visor: While useful, some might prefer a removable option for varied riding conditions.
Adjustability: The helmet has fewer adjustment points compared to other high-end models, though the dial offers good fit customization.

The SMITH Convoy MTB Cycling Helmet truly excels in combining critical safety features with comfort and functionality tailored for mountain biking. With its thoughtful design and high-quality materials, it’s easy to see why this helmet is a favorite among MTB enthusiasts. Whether you’re navigating rocky trails or enjoying a leisurely off-road ride, the Convoy has got you covered.

Comparison of Cycling Helmets

When it comes to choosing the perfect mountain bike helmet, you have three fantastic options: the Giro Manifest Spherical, the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic with MIPS, and the SMITH Convoy MTB helmet. All three offer unique features catering to your safety, comfort, and performance on the trails. Let’s break down the specifications and help you decide which one suits your needs best.

Specifications Overview

Feature	Giro Manifest Spherical	Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic	SMITH Convoy MTB
Technology	Spherical Technology, Powered By MIPS	MIPS	MIPS Safety Protection System
Construction	In-Mold with Progressive Layering, Full Lower Hardbody Coverage	Reinforced Polycarbonate Shell In-Molded, EPS Liner	Lightweight Protection
Ventilation	19 Wind Tunnel Vents with Internal Channeling	16 Vented Ports (8 Front, 8 Back)	20 Fixed Vents, AirEvac System
Fit System	Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System	Triple Position Adjustable Retention System	Adjustable Dial on Back
Weight	340g (Size Medium)	Not specified	Not specified
Other Features	N/A	Customizable Fit, Washable Liner, Adjustable Visor	Fixed Visor, CPSC & CE EN 1078 Certified, Integrates with Smith Eyewear
Brand Heritage	Established in Cycling Gear	40 Years of Racing Experience	Performance-Focused, Established in Eyewear and Helmets

Detailed Comparison

Giro Manifest Spherical Helmet

The Giro Manifest Spherical helmet is designed with cutting-edge safety and comfort technologies. The Spherical Technology powered by MIPS ensures you get top-notch impact management. With its unique in-mold construction and progressive layering, this helmet offers superior protection along with full lower hardbody coverage. The Roc Loc Trail Air Fit System allows you to adjust the fit perfectly, ensuring your helmet stays secure. With 19 wind tunnel vents, this helmet provides excellent ventilation to keep you cool and comfortable during intense rides.

Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS

The Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic helmet brings a blend of safety, comfort, and customization. Featuring a polycarbonate shell in-molded with an EPS liner, it is designed to offer maximum protection. The MIPS technology incorporated adds an extra layer of safety by reducing rotational forces. This helmet boasts 16 vented ports strategically placed to optimize airflow and cooling. The triple position adjustable retention system allows for a tailored fit, and the ultra-plush, removable, and washable liner ensures comfort and hygiene. The adjustable visor adds convenience, making it versatile for various riding conditions.

SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet

The SMITH Convoy MTB helmet is an excellent option for those seeking a balanced mix of protection, ventilation, and fit. It comes with the MIPS Safety Protection System, ensuring a high level of impact management. Certified to CPSC and CE EN 1078 standards, this helmet is designed for reliability. The 20 fixed vents, combined with the AirEvac system, provide consistent airflow to keep you cool and prevent your eyewear from fogging. The adjustable dial on the back allows you to fine-tune the fit for maximum comfort. Additionally, the fixed visor and integration with Smith eyewear enhance its practicality and user experience.

Which Helmet to Choose?

Best for Advanced Safety and Ventilation: If you prioritize advanced safety technology and superior ventilation, the Giro Manifest Spherical is perfect for you.
Best for Customization and Comfort: If you desire a customizable fit and maximum comfort, consider the Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS.
Best for All-round Protection and Fit: For balanced protection, fit, and a focus on eyewear integration, the SMITH Convoy MTB Helmet is an excellent choice.

Each of these helmets caters to specific needs. Evaluate your priorities and choose the one that aligns with your preferences to ensure a safe and enjoyable ride. Happy biking! 🚵‍♂️😄

Conclusion: A Friendly Roundup of MTB Helmets

Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet – Men’s

The Giro Manifest Spherical Cycling Helmet is a top-tier choice for serious mountain bikers looking for maximum protection and comfort. Its advanced Spherical Technology by MIPS offers enhanced safety by managing rotational forces in case of an impact. The adjustable fit system and well-placed ventilation ensure you stay comfortable on long rides. However, some users may find the more premium price tag a bit steep.

Troy Lee Designs Adult | All Mountain | Mountain Bike | A1 Classic Helmet with MIPS

The Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet is a blend of style, comfort, and safety. With MIPS technology and a durable polycarbonate shell, you get excellent protection. The helmet’s classy design and multiple color options make it a favorite among style-conscious riders. The helmet’s fit system is quite effective, although a few users have mentioned it can feel snug if you have a larger head.

SMITH Convoy MTB Cycling Helmet – Adult Mountain Bike Helmet with MIPS Technology + Visor

The SMITH Convoy MTB Cycling Helmet is a lightweight, highly functional option that won’t break the bank. Equipped with MIPS technology and a removable visor, it’s perfect for both men and women mountain bikers. The easy-to-adjust fit system and adequate ventilation make it a comfortable option for extended use. However, it may not offer the same high-end features or aesthetic appeal as the other more expensive models.

Final Recommendation

Each of these helmets brings something different to the table:

Opt for the Giro Manifest Spherical if you’re seeking top-notch safety features and are willing to invest for premium quality.
The Troy Lee Designs A1 Classic Helmet is ideal if you desire a helmet that combines style and safety, particularly if you have a medium-sized head.
Choose the SMITH Convoy MTB if you’re looking for a budget-friendly, lightweight option that still offers solid protection and convenience.

Whatever your choice, rest assured that each helmet is built to keep you safe and comfortable as you hit the trails! Safe riding! 🚵‍♀️🚵‍♂️

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.